Last week, the New York Times wrote a story on the findings of a study on the graduates of a marquee teacher training program, Teach For America. The study’s aim was to find out what the level of civic engagement was for the alums of the program, after they completed their two year commitment to teaching. They were surprised to find that civic involvement was lower than expected. Since the US Public Service Academy was founded by two TFA alums and several of our volunteer coordinators are too, not to mention that TFA fully endorses the legislation, I wanted you to hear directly from Genevieve Quist, a TFA alum and the California State Coordinator for our Youth Advisory Councils. ~Justine Hebron
Part of my motivation for acting as California’s State Coordinator in USPSA’s efforts is rooted directly in my experience as a Teach For America corps member. I liked the idea of making public service more accessible to college students, and providing those future public servants with a rigorous education. What got me hooked, however, was the initial comparison made to Teach For America. What kept me going through my 70 hour work weeks, in addition to the amazing kids in my Los Angeles classroom, was my belief that I was part of a larger movement working towards something critically important- educational equity. The culture that I observed and participated in, both as a corps member and as staff at the Summer Institute training program, was one of professionalism, dedication to students and the larger mission, and relentless pursuit of results. What if building a United States Public Service Academy could do for jobs in government what Teach For America has done for teaching positions in low-income public schools?
My experience in the classroom propelled me towards graduate research in Social Policy, will guide me in the policy and advocacy job market when I complete my degree, and has encouraged me to consistently give money and time to child focused non-profits and legislative efforts. Teach For America is the most formative professional experience I’ve had. Stanford’s study, “Assessing the Long-Term Effects of Youth Service: The Puzzling Case of Teach For America”, suggests that not all corps members feel the same way I do:
“Financed by the William T. Grant Foundation, the study surveyed every person who was accepted by Teach for America from 1993 to 1998. It is being published this month in Social Forces, a journal published by the University of North Carolina. The study compared “graduates,” who completed their two years; “dropouts,” who entered the program but left before the two years were up; and “nonmatriculants,” who were accepted but declined the offer. It included 1,538 graduates, 324 dropouts and 634 nonmatriculants. Nearly 45 percent of those sampled returned the 34-page survey.
While Teach for America graduates remain far more active than their peer group, the findings indicate that the program neither achieves an earlier organizational goal of “making citizens” nor produces people who, in great numbers, take their civic commitments beyond the field of education.”
Does this imply that my original motivation for supporting USPSA was somehow flawed? I completed Teach For America three years ago, but my teaching experience is still relatively fresh in my mind. Do the study results foreshadow a possible future self- more cynical, less engaged? Regardless of the results of this study, I believe it is possible for an organization to instill a culture and create a network that can work for the broader good in a systemic, long term capacity. Although the verdict on TFA may still be unclear, and perhaps hard to ever measure accurately, I believe the United States Public Service Academy’s impact on our generation may be quite powerful.
USPSA students will enroll at 18, graduate at about 21, and then work in public service through age 26; this experience will help to create a cohesive culture of service among America’s youth. When I was in college, and trying to figure out what I wanted to do with my life after graduating, one of Teach For America’s recruitment flyers caught my attention. It asked: “Over 90% of members of Congress have law degrees. What would our country look like if over 90% had experience teaching in a low-income public school?” What would our country look like if more talented, rigorously trained college seniors committed to a wide spectrum of public service positions? Passing H.R. 2102 will help us find out. ~Genevieve Quist




