Currently, the USPSA Blueprint Advisory Board is developing its second draft of the Blueprint, a document that will guide the creation of the Academy once the legislation is passed.
The creation of a meaningful Blueprint will require serious discussion about a wide range of issues. Everything — admissions requirements, curriculum, sports teams, tenure — is on the table at this point. This period stands as a unique opportunity for those who love the Academy idea to play a crucial role in its establishment. We genuinely want and need to hear input from you.
To this end, this blog will be offering up a series of “Reader Response” posts, each of which will focus on a particular aspect of the Academy. The comments logged here will be read and seriously considered by those who are responsible for guiding the direction of the Academy. This is your chance to be involved in the formation of America’s next great institution.
On the table this week: Should Academy students wear uniforms?
Although the USPSA will be a civilian college, the official proposal states that “the campus
ethos and daily pace of life will be more akin to a military academy than a typical liberal arts college.” As the civilian counterpart to the military academy model, some have suggested that the Academy should require its students to wear uniforms as a widely-recognized sign of their commitment to service.
What do you think?
Skeets Houglund responded on 12 Mar 2008 at 5:15 pm #
I have spent 20 years in the business world working for Fortune 500 companies, and have also help start several non-profit agencies. I have seen men’s dress requirements go from formal suits and ties to “casual Friday’s” to jeans and clothing of questionable suitability for a professional environment and rebound somewhere short of suit and tie in a gray area known as “business casual”.
I agree that militaristic uniforms may restrict to a degree the nature of the academy as an institution that promotes innovative thought and solutions. However, as has been pointed out, you have to build a sense of cause greater than oneself and remove the outward symbols of socio-economic status and any type of pre-judging associated with allowing people the freedom to dress as they please.
If the tuition is to be paid for by the government, students should expect to be required to wear a uniform, just as they would at a job. A comfortable, yet practical uniform is probably expected to be worn by most people who would apply to the academy.
I have seen public secondary schools implement uniform policies that give students the choice of which uniforms to wear and that leads to a sense of disharmony. On any given day, you would see students with mismatched shirts or pants that while technically adhering to the uniform policy, didn’t create a uniform appearance for the student body on the day in questions. You would have to have everyone in the same uniform at the same time much like the service academies, or you run the risk of people pushing the envelope on uniform requirements.
I think ties for men are a thing of the past. In business, many regions in the country wear ties only for formal occasions. Look at Bill Gates and the leadership of for-profit corporations. Bill is often seen in a crisp button down collar shirt, cashmere v-neck and nice slacks. A tie is uncomfortable and constricts blood flow (or at least it feels like it if you’re sitting in a classroom). Like public schools, the tie is prone to being loosely knotted or all matter of varied ways. Take the tie for men out of the daily uniform requirements and reserve it only for formal occasions.
The other factor with the tie and/or business dress is that in many of the areas the graduates will be serving the public service, the style of business dress can raise barriers between them and the very public they are trying to help. Additionally, slacks and a dress shirt may not be very practical in helping build houses or tend to the sick or elderly. Maybe some form of stylized medical “scrub” or similar unique uniform, short white lab coat, or something similar might work, along with published standards on how they should be worn.
There should also be some thought given to grooming standards. While military haircuts aren’t necessarily suggested or desired, personal grooming is also open to variants in socio-economic class and pre-judging. Right or wrong, people make their first impression when meeting a new person during the first 15 seconds of their encounter. A person with long, matted hair and untrimmed facial hair may overshadow the actual talent of the individual at least in the eyes of those people they may be trying to assist.
Lastly, think of a uniform as trying to establish a “brand” image for the U.S. Public Service Academy. If there were a set of uniforms required at the Academy AND during the 5 years of public service following graduation, this would help stimulate recognition of the Academy.
Many things to think about, but this is probably one of the first questions prospective candidates will ask when considering the academy.
Hans Solo responded on 15 Jun 2008 at 5:28 am #
Are you suggesting that a blazer and decent pair of slacks is ‘militaristic’? Please, if one feels his ability to think creatively is hindered by the clothes he is wearing than I doubt he ever had an original thought to begin with.
Why uniforms then? Unless I missed it on my quick skim through the above arguments, no one has touched on one of the primary reasons the academies wear uniforms. First of all, when you are in uniform, you are identifiable. The world looks at you and says, “he/she’s a Cadet, I expect more from them.”
And you deliver. Putting on the uniform means you cannot hide behind anonymity. The blazer, as silly as it may seem, comes with a lot of expectation and responsibility. And believe me, people behave a lot differently in uniform than out- because they are literally wearing the pride of their beloved institution, and wouldn’t dare behave in such a way as to disgrace it.
JSCAM87 responded on 23 Aug 2009 at 7:10 am #
I think the Uniform question is a good indication of the wide range of views of people and what they want out of the newest Service Academy. Some people seem to want the ‘free ride’ to never end. Others want it to be difficult. I think if this new school wants to be considered a Federal Service Academy, they should earn that title. A quick reference for all the Service Academies can be found at http://toughestschoolsintheworld.com/ .
Interesting conversation…
Coarintigiork responded on 07 Mar 2012 at 7:09 am #
get genuine and unique products delivered to you suitable at your doorstep, supplying you with much more convenience anddealer to seller and distributor to distributor also.All that you have to do being a purchaser is to researchto view many web-sites as of late which can be from the small business of promoting second hand bags on-line. Essentially the mosttime, the shop comes with great lower price gives you and product sales, which aid to avoid wasting additional money.In the event you desire aall around in markets. On the other hand, this is extra cumbersome, and will also require quite a bit of time on the conclusion.In some Monster Headphones have distinctive presents, however the customer must determine what on earth is most effective for her. Buying Chanel On the web Everyday living typicallyworld, and each Chanel handbag is really wonderful and magnificent.Nevertheless, perfection and genuine course happensthat need to fulfilled initially together with the web site, such as turning into a registered member, and providing somelooking out for info with your place or city, and browsing for sellers in town directories, or by inquiringis going to be really worth the attempt, for the reason that the prices on the goods are going to be pretty low, maintaining in brain the